Do it. |
As writers, we get trolled a lot. One day we're just beep-boopin along, and then suddenly somebody comments on a piece of flash fiction or a novel excerpt and lets us know just ~what they think~ in a nice array of SUPER flattering text.
Example: "omg you call this fiction?!!?! more like dumpster trash lololol"
okay, so that's a crappy example. Forgive me, been a long work day and I should go crash soon. Anyway, at first you think "Wow, that sucks. Thanks for ruining my day, bro," but then you think "bwahahaha they probably didn't even read it."
It's kind of the same with some bad reviews, especially from random strangers. Of course, genuine "bad reviews" are not fun at all, but many see them as learning experiences if it's applicable. It never feels good to have something you worked so hard and long at be treated like crap, but it's usually easier when it comes from a stranger,
Then there's the bad reviews from your fellow writers. I don't know about you, but those are the ones that strike through me the hardest.
We writers are critical. We're hard on ourselves (or at least should be) and tend to be hard on other writers. It's why the beta process can be so important. We need our fellow writers to be critical, both in terms of what works and what doesn't.
Thus, it hurts doubly when they hate something we've done than when Joe Schmoe goes on a tangent.
Let's face it, y'all writers, deep down we all compete with each other. Perhaps not always monetarily and with sales, but at least mentally - we will always compare ourselves to every writer we come across. We'll bite our lips when somebody does something we've always wanted to be able to do so well, and we'll smugly think "haha I would never do that at least!" we see something we don't like at all. And of course, there's that pang of jealousy whenever somebody lands a book deal when we're still struggling. But of course we'll happily congratulate them and share in their excitement. Most of the time.
These aren't bad things. They're human nature. (Well, you could argue that it could be bad because it IS human nature..) But they're real. And it affects the way we interact with each other. It's easy to disregard somebody's writing as trash on days we're particularly down on ourselves and looking for validation. But I digress.
I apparently need to close up this blog entry now because I am making less and less sense (or just getting more and more tired) as time goes on: but basically, "trolls" are easy to write off (haha get it!!!) because ~what do they know~? But writers man, writers hatin' on your stuff is like a punch to the back of the head. Because what if they're right?
This post is brought to you by a good idea I had that's been tainted by a 12 hour work day and even less sleep to back it up. I'm off to rectify that last point right now. Goodnight~
Is there any one kind of review you just can't deal with even on a good day?
I can't deal with any comments unless they say how awesome I am.
ReplyDelete;)
DeleteUgh, that would have to be vague critiques!
ReplyDeleteI can handle having my work torn to pieces. You can even tell me I write complete and utter drivel. But I cannot stand vague critiques!
Well, a vague critique would certainly be unhelpful, especially if you can't even decide if they liked your work or not.
DeleteI would much rather have someone tell me something completely doesn't work than say something is mediocre because then I worry that a complete overhaul could make it worse. If it's already bad, things have to get better.
ReplyDeleteHm, that's an interesting take. Usually for me if somebody says something is just okay then it's fairly easy for me to "fix" if I deem it needs to be. Overhauls are the bane of my writing existence.
DeleteI try really hard any time I put something out on my blog to be prepared to suck up the bad with the good. I also try to remind myself that I need to at least evaluate the negative comments to see if there is any reality in it. It's not a comfortable feeling at all.
ReplyDeleteI think that's what we go through any time we post something on the web, or at least that's my experience after all these years. Post comments, forum posts, blog posts, fan-fiction, articles, etc etc it's all up for "public" scrutiny.
DeleteI haven't had too many negative experiences on the web. Guess I'm lucky.
ReplyDeleteBtw, with the campaign. Hi, and nice to meet you!
Wow, I would say that's pretty lucky indeed! I don't think I can go four days without something ragequitworthy happening.
DeleteAnd nice to meet you too!
I seem to collect and eventually befriend about 60% of my trolls, including the one who never-ever failed to tell me on almost everything I posted what an incompetent and boring boob am I, and how the only-only-only real reason I'm on the net is because I lack satisfying sex in my life. Most of them are pathologically weirdos (just like me), and when you get to know them privately they're stories in themselves.
ReplyDeleteOf course, every time you post fiction to pass judgement, that's what you're going get. But that's what you want don't you? No, I don't mean the kick in the teeth from when you first read it, and it makes you feel like poop on the bottom of someone's shoe. I mean after you got over that feeling, and got over "Fk-it! I'm NEVER writing again!" and you get to the part of: "Hmmmm... how can I fix it?"
That's when I'm happy I had to go through the poop on the shoe feeling, because when I fix it, it sounds better. And you probably already know that a lit agent will only say "NO!" and never tell you why.
I'll never understand the troll. Now, Weissdorn, do you have magic troll dust?
ReplyDeleteHi there, stopping in from the Fantasy group at the Campaign!
ReplyDeleteAh, reviews and critiques . . . I have to say that I've had a few strange ones. The least helpful one I've ever had? Someone critiqued a short story of mine, and I had some very specific criteria that I had to follow for a contest. The suggestions they made pretty much said they didn't even listen to what I said. It was frustrating.
Hi Hildred - I've never heard that name before. Kind of a cross between Mildred and Hilda. :-)
ReplyDeleteStopping by from fantasy list of campaigners.
I don't mind critical reviews that have intelligent things to say. That's how I learn. I haven't had any experiences with true trolls yet, but it's only a matter of time, I'm sure.
The only thing that bugs me is if someone posts a really low rating on GoodReads or Amazon but doesn't say why. As a writer, I'm honestly curious as to what didn't work for the reader. I can choose to ignore it or take it into consideration if it's common feedback.
Probably because it shares the same roots as both names ;) (although for the record, neither is my name. I've been called both enough times by now. It also is not Hildegarde.)
DeleteI think for a lot of people who give low reviews and don't say why, it's a combination of laziness and just "meh, I just didn't like it/care for it. Moving on now." Works for them, but not so much for us.